The finest guidebook ever written for the
Big Island and the only one written by writers who anonymously review the island. They visit every beach, restaurant, activity and trail on the island. The result is this comprehensive, humorous and easy-to-read full color guide that will lead you to more adventures than any other book. A must for travelers.
Hawaii Tweets
Tags:
Hawaii,
scot,
King,
Big Island,
islan,
Hospitality Recreation,
writer
Related posts:
- Lonely Planet Hawaii (Regional Travel Guide)
- Which Island of Hawaii is the best to visit?
- Extended Hawaii Vacations: A Great Way To Experience Living In Hawaii Firsthand
- HawaiiTours.com Adds New Adventurous Tours to Their Website
- Lonely Planet Hawaii (Regional Travel Guide)
The best and worst,
This is a hard one to review, because while this and the others in the series are wonderfully organized, expertly written and unbelievably detailed, they also reveal the deepest secrets of the Hawaiian Islands, previously only known to locals.
First, the positives. You won’t find a better tour book for Hawaii, on or off the islands – period. This goes for every book of the series – Maui, Oahu, Kauai and the Big Island. Doughty and Friedman expertly steer you around the islands, avoiding the crowds and avoiding the tourist traps (like the bike ride down Haleakala). You’ll get tons of practical touring strategies, like, for example, on Maui, taking the Road to Hana later in the day and spending the night in Hana so you can have the Seven Pools to yourself for a few hours in the morning. That’s just one example from the series; each and every book is loaded with this kind of pragmatism, so even on your first trip you’ll feel like a seasoned visitor.
Every aspect of your trip is covered in the books, from the sites to see and avoid, the restaurants to hit, the best hotels, camping options, and island history. Every type of traveler from the luxury $1000 per night tourist to the canvas tent hiker will find useful info. More than anything, while realizing how much of Hawaii is truly still hidden to you in the almost uninhabitable reaches of the jungles and volcanic residues, you’ll still feel as though you’re seeing as much of it as any outsider can see.
Now for the bad. Because Doughty and Friedman live on the islands and have explored every hidden waterfall and pool, they are privy to spots on the islands that even many locals are unaware of. And naturally, many of the areas are located on private property. This however, doesn’t seem to bother the writers. After giving a detailed description of how to access a remote waterfall on private property (stuff like, “Park on the pull-off a few hundred yards after mile-marker 23, and scale the guardrail. You should see a path that winds down into a bamboo forest. At the bottom of the path, go *left*, not right, away from the river…” etc.), they follow it up with a limp disclaimer, like “Technically, this is Hawaiian Forest and Game property, but we’ve been hiking on it for years without a problem…” The bottom line is that while the places they tell you to go are private and amazing, by definition these magnificent spots can’t last. Because they’ve been revealed (as the book titles promise), a hidden location that may have previously had only a few dozen visitors per year now gets five or six visitors a day, thus destroying the serenity and privacy of the location, ruining what is the reason for going there in the first place. So it’s somewhat of a self-defeating book, since by revealing these remote locations they are also condemning them to extinction.
Lastly, these books are quite popular and already the hidden waterfalls and trails are not so hidden. More than once I hiked a mile or two through rough, muddy terrain and rushing rivers to reach a waterfall, where I found a soccer mom, an over-weight dad in flip-flops, and two four-year olds frolicking in the pool, one of the inevitably clutching their copy of “Maui Revealed” or “Oahu Revealed.” That sort of detracts from the sense of adventure I built up on the way there. In addition, some of the private property areas that he says have no signs posted now have “Keep Out!” signs posted in response to the hundreds of trespassers following Doughty and Friedman’s advice. So be aware that some trails they mention as remote and tolerant of hikers may now be *very* intolerant to trespassers.
While this book is an incredible guidebook and you *should* use it to plan your Hawaiian vacation, ultimately, let your conscience be your guide as to where you do and don’t venture.
Was this review helpful to you?
|Lots of useful tips, but lots of dated material,
The strengths of this book lie in the authors’ thorough local knowledge of the island. For example, if you’re interested in finding hidden beaches, volcanic pools, self-drive advice into the Waipio Valley, and so forth, this is probably the best book for these kinds of tips. They are excellent at detailing the logistics of seeing island sights on your own (exactly when, how, etc.). They also warn about potential difficulties you might encounter, such as tourist scams or signs indicating a private road when the road is in fact public (Waipi’o Valley).
It has some serious weaknesses, however, when it comes to its sometimes heavy-handed opinions on local businesses. One example is the Red Sail Dive operation in Kohala. I signed up with them despite the authors’ description: “Groups are held on a tight leash. Get in, get out, let’s go, next site. We received no briefing whatsoever.” Since they had a desk at the hotel where I was staying, I dove with them, and found this description to be completely inaccurate. I asked one of the instructors about that, and he said that it was like that 10 years ago (certainly not in the five years he worked there). This advice was been repeated in the newest edition, leading me to believe that once the authors form an opinion, they often stick with it rather than re-evaluating it for subsequent editions. It would be more accurate for them to say “When we last dove with them in 1996,…”
Another glaring example for me was their review of the Hapuna Beach Prince Hotel, which they don’t recommend. I more often than not stay at 4* properties, and this is one of the nicest hotels at which I’ve stayed. It’s rated #1 out of 70 hotels on the island of Hawaii on tripadvisor.com (based on 229 reviews), so my opinion doesn’t seem to be off-base. What’s even more striking is that they recommend the sister property, the Mauna Kea Hotel, which is over 30 years older, has smaller rooms, less attractive common areas, and a less attractive beach.
Their restaurant reviews also seemed based on the authors’ limited experience. They didn’t recommend the Tres Hombres in Kawaihae, yet I found this to be one of the only affordable places for a decent meal in the northern Kohala resort area (where it’s otherwise nearly impossible to get a dinner for two without drinks for under $100). They did recommend the Grand Palace Chinese restaurant in southern Kohala which had some of the blandest Chinese food I’ve had.
As a final example, their helicopter section doesn’t even mention Paradise Helicopters, which not only has the lowest-priced volcano/falls tour from Hilo, but also has all-window seat flights (unlike most companies) with 2-way headphones. We found them (and got a discount) through Tom Barefoot.
In summary, if you have a car and time to tour the island, you will probably want to buy this book for its precise and accurate geographical and logistical information. It also has good background information in an easy-to-read writing style. I would be very wary of their opinions on local businesses, however, since these opinions seem to be made on the basis of limited experience. Therefore, this book wouldn’t be too useful for someone who plans to just spend a few days in his hotel and not rent a car.
Was this review helpful to you?
|